Murr Capital

Guides

How to read a small business's tax returns before you buy

· 8 min read

The profit and loss a seller hands you is their version of the year. The tax return is the version they filed with the IRS. Before you buy a small business, read both. A listing can look tidy and still sit on numbers that do not tie out.

This is a practical way to read those returns. It is general education, not a loan offer, and not legal, tax, or financial advice. Have your own accountant walk the forms with you before you make an offer.

What to ask for, and how many years

Ask for the federal income tax returns the business filed, for the three most recent years that are already filed. If one year looks odd, or the work is seasonal, ask for a fourth year so you can see whether the odd year is a habit. If the latest year is not filed yet, ask for the books that year will be built from, and note that the return does not exist yet.

The form depends on how the business pays tax:

A cover sheet is not the return. Ask for the schedules, including Form 4562 when they filed depreciation, any statement of officer pay, and Schedule L when the return has a balance sheet. Ask for state returns where the business files them, and for the amended copy if a year was changed.

For each year, also ask for the year-end profit and loss and balance sheet the seller uses internally. Use the same twelve months. Do not line a calendar-year return up with a July-to-June profit and loss unless the seller shows the overlap.

How the return compares with the profit and loss

Set the two documents for the same year side by side and start with revenue. The top line on the return and the top line on the profit and loss should be close. A small gap can be timing. A wide gap needs a written explanation you can check against bank deposits.

Profit will often disagree, because the two documents are not showing one shared take-home number.

On a Schedule C, profit is before the owner's personal draw. A draw is not a business expense. If the profit and loss subtracts owner draw the way it subtracts rent, it is showing a smaller profit than the return.

On an S corporation, owner wages are an expense on Form 1120-S. A distribution is not. Cash to the owner is wages plus distributions. If a recast adds both, check that the distribution was not already left out of expenses. Counting it twice makes the business look stronger than the return.

A partnership works the same way. Guaranteed payments are an expense. Other cash paid to partners often is not. Read the K-1 beside the profit and loss before you treat one owner-benefit line as money you will receive.

Depreciation sits on the return, and it is not cash that left the account that week. If the profit and loss shows a different figure than Form 4562, ask why. The machines still wear out either way.

The return says whether the books are cash or accrual. The profit and loss should say the same thing. Cash records money when it moves. Accrual records a sale when it is earned and a bill when it is incurred. If the seller cannot name the method on each document, you do not have a comparison yet.

Add-backs, and why to be careful

Sellers often recast earnings by adding expenses back. The claim is that some costs were personal, happened once, or belong to this owner, so a buyer would not pay them. The return is the list of costs the business actually deducted.

If a cost is not on the return, it was not deducted. You cannot add back a cost the business did not claim. When the seller says the car, the phone, or a relative's pay was personal, those amounts should sit on a line you can point to. A number with no line under it is a hope.

If the cost is on the return, the business reported it as a cost of operating. Adding it back means you believe you will not pay it. A personal car or a relative who will leave can be fair. You may still need a car, or a manager if the owner was the manager. Write that replacement next to the add-back, or the price runs ahead of the cash.

Use all three years, not the year the seller prefers. A repair called one-time that shows up every year is not one-time. Adding depreciation back raises earnings on paper and still leaves you with assets that wear out. Ask the age of the main assets and what replacing them costs.

Red flags on the returns

None of these, on its own, proves the seller is hiding the truth. Each one is a reason to slow down and ask for the bridge between the documents.

Tax returns are private. BizFacts pulls public records on a business. Read those beside the returns. They are not a stand-in for the forms.

When the numbers do not match

Build a one-page bridge for each year. Four lines are enough to start: revenue on the return, revenue on the profit and loss, profit on the return, and the seller's earnings number. Subtract. Whatever remains has to be explained with a line on a form, a bank statement, or an invoice.

Ask for that bridge in writing. A useful answer is a list: owner wages, a draw, a personal car, a deposit that belongs in another year. Your accountant can test a list. A story with no list is not a bridge.

While you wait, DealBrain analyzes a deal you're looking at. It does not replace the returns.

If the seller will not provide the returns, write that down. You can pause, pay less because the proof is thin, or walk away. Do not fill the hole with a number you made up, and do not recast earnings you cannot tie to a filed form. When a year looks strong on the listing and weak on the return, bank deposits for that year are the third column.

Put the returns next to the rest of the deal

Hand the bridge to your accountant before you settle on a price. How to evaluate a small business for sale covers the lease and the owner's daily role. What it costs to buy a small business separates the asking price from the cash the business needs after you own it.

When one business is worth putting on a single page, open it in DealBrain. DealBrain analyzes a deal you're looking at. Murr Capital is the capital partner on that path. We find the money for you. Little or $0 of your own money is the goal. Your accountant still has to be comfortable with the returns before you sign.

Questions buyers ask about the returns

How many years of tax returns should I ask for?

Ask for three filed years, and a fourth when a year looks odd or the business is seasonal. If the latest year is not filed, ask for the books behind it and mark the return as missing.

Should the tax return match the profit and loss?

Revenue for the same twelve months should be close. Profit often will not match, because wages, draws, distributions, and depreciation sit in different places. Ask for a written bridge for the gap.

How should I treat an add-back?

Find the cost on the return, then ask whether you will still pay something like it. A personal car can be a fair add-back. Depreciation you add back still leaves assets that wear out. A figure with no line on the return is a guess.

What if the seller will not share the returns?

Treat the refusal as part of the file. Pause, price the missing proof, or walk away. Do not invent earnings to fill the gap.